JoburgCAN calls on City of Joburg to overhaul discriminatory refuse and sanitation tariffs.
“These Joburg tariffs do not follow the requirements of the National Treasury’s tariff setting methodology,” according to Julia Fish, manager of JoburgCAN.
Image: JoburgCAN
JoburgCAN, an initiative of OUTA, believes the City of Johannesburg’s sanitation and refuse tariffs are discriminatory.
“The City flouts National Treasury standards, charging tariffs using indefensible methodologies based on the size of properties rather than on consumption, making the practice unfair,” according to Fish. “The City’s budget and tariffs do not allow for residents to make lifestyle adjustments to save money and make bills affordable by lowering their consumption, as levies and taxes are charged in a way that does not take usage into account,” says Fish.
The regulatory framework that defines how a municipality sets and administers tariffs, section 74 of the Municipal Systems Act, states that users of municipal services should be treated equitably in the application of tariffs and the amount individual users pay for services should generally be in proportion to their use of that service. Poor households must have access to at least basic services through tariffs that cover only operating and maintenance costs, special tariffs or life-line tariffs for low levels of use, or other direct subsidies.
This section states that “tariffs must reflect the costs reasonably associated with rendering the service” and that a tariff policy may differentiate between different categories of users “as long as the differentiation does not amount to unfair discrimination”.
The City of Johannesburg offers these domestic sanitation tariffs:
- A flat rate per erf per month based on the size of the erf plus a demand management levy and VAT; or
- A block rising tariff based on water consumption for those on prepaid water meters, plus a demand management levy and VAT. (This is deemed to be applicable currently only to households benefitting from, for example, the Soweto Infrastructure Project and new private developments where prepayment meters are installed).
The Medium-Term Budget 2023/24 – 2025/26 document does not provide any explanation for the alternative sanitation tariffs or why only some households are permitted to access the tariff linked to water usage.
JoburgCAN believes that the method used to levy sanitation charges based on the size of the property for residential users is incorrect and indefensible. There is no logical comparison between the size of the property and the volume of waste water to be treated by the municipality. A fair and reasonable allocation of costs that determine tariff setting cannot be linked to the difference in categories of consumers if done to value rather than consumption.
In terms of refuse charges and solid waste removal, the draft budget for 2024/25 says Pikitup has, since 2016 , moved away from charging for waste management services (refuse removal) based on the number of bins to charging a levy based on the market value of property instead.
Fish says “JoburgCAN believes the refuse charge also amounts to unfair discrimination against some users, as users with different use of the service will pay the same amount for waste services within each value block. This discrimination is amplified by the impact of the rising block tariff approach followed. Although tariffs based on property value are generally regarded as a strong proxy for income and thus affordability, the relationship may be poor which will also result in unfair discrimination.”
Non-residential properties are charged a city cleansing levy instead of refuse removal. This is also based on the value of the property.
“JoburgCAN therefore regards the City’s waste management tariffs as incorrect and indefensible. There is no logical comparison between the value of a property and the refuse charge or the city cleansing levy to be collected,” says Fish
In our response to the City’s draft budget and proposed tariffs, JoburgCAN calls on the City to address this inequality and align the tariffs to the Standardised Tariff Setting Methodology issued by National Treasury.
A soundclip with comment by Julia Fish, the Manager at JoburgCAN, is here.
JoburgCAN made a detailed submission to the City of Johannesburg, strongly criticising the draft budget and IDP. See more here.
More about JoburgCAN is here.
JoburgCAN is an initiative of OUTA and was established to improve service delivery, engage in local government affairs, and foster community within the City. JoburgCAN represents affiliates and supporters residing in all seven regions of the City. As a properly established community-based organisation, JoburgCAN acts in unity and on behalf of its affiliates and supporters.
I say that costs must be allocated and taking into account, amount of waste/refuse to be removed, efforts to remove the waste/refuse and infrastructure. There must be a fixed rate per bin per property, and all properties must be charged the same. A Surcharge must be allocated to problematic areas – which needs more revenue and attention to get the waste removed – such as a location, where there is debris, waste and rubbish thrown on the ground, streets and dumped in piles (this must have a surcharge) as PickIt Up will have more efforts and costs in problematic areas, than areas where all residents take out their bins in a timely manner, and make use of them as needed – with no hassle. ALSO the rate and charge being linked to the property value is completely unreasonable- example, you may have a property worth R2.5 Million with only 2 occupants, yet they are charged over inflated rates due to the property value; as on the other hand you may have a small dwelling in Soweto, renting it out to 10 occupants, yet the value is only regarded as half a million. We need a universal rate/charge system irregardless of the area, property value etc. It must be based on the amount of resources used from the council to be able to render a service.
As a single occupier pensioner of a modest home on a largish plot, I totally agree! My neighbours on my left are a 7 household family and on my right are a 10 household family, both on similar sized stands. Both family’s water usage and consequently their sewage discharge must be massively more than mine, yet we get charged the same sewerage cost! Totally iniquitous and discriminatory to pensioners. I did a comparison of our respective charges between Cape Town, where sewerage costs are based on 60% of household comparison and Joburg, where it is based on stand size and in 6 months, Joburg costs were over R3,000 more
Thanks for tackling this matter! I am also a pensioner using VERY little water, and being charged the same as neighbours with 6people living on their property, who also have a regular gardener who uses massive quantities of water hosing down a brick driveway. ie also equates to 7persons using sewerage facilities!!
I do trust all the ideas youve presented in your post They are really convincing and will definitely work Nonetheless the posts are too short for newbies May just you please lengthen them a bit from next time Thank you for the post
Awesome page with genuinely good material for readers wanting to gain some useful insights on that topic! But if you want to learn more, check out UQ8 about Airport Transfer. Keep up the great work!
1xBet промокод предоставляет уникальную возможность увеличить депозит при первом депозите. Для получения бонуса с 1xBet промокодом, требуется зарегистрироваться на сервисе 1xBet и указать специальный код при внесении первого депозита.
Получить промокод 1xBet очень просто — на этапе создания учетной записи. Бонусный код 1xBet для новичков предоставит шанс получить стартовый бонус. Стартовый бонус предлагается новичкам и обеспечивает дополнительные средства для ставок.
[url=https://medium.com/@mamaevpavel864/промокод-1хбет-как-найти-67fdf0d3ea0f]1xBet промокод – получите до 100% бонуса[/url]
Активируйте промокод 1xBet для удвоения депозита. Как ввести промокод 1xBet? Всё интуитивно понятно: при пополнении счета введите код в специальном окне.
Если вы хотите максимизировать свой депозит, воспользуйтесь нашим руководством, чтобы ввести промокод 1xBet. Уникальный код 1xBet даёт дополнительные бонусы, что увеличит ваш потенциал. Промокоды для регистрации всегда дают наилучшие бонусы, чтобы стартовать с максимальной выгодой.
Получите всё по максимуму, вводя эксклюзивный промокод 1xBet при первой пополнении счета.
Также полезно ознакомиться с отзывами и мнениями экспертов о спортивных событиях, чтобы всегда знать актуальное и получить советы по ставкам. Специальные предложения по промокоду позволят вам больше выигрывать.
[url=https://medium.com/@mamaevpavel864/%D0%BF%D1%80%D0%BE%D0%BC%D0%BE%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%B4-1%D1%85%D0%B1%D0%B5%D1%82-%D0%BA%D0%B0%D0%BA-%D0%BD%D0%B0%D0%B9%D1%82%D0%B8-67fdf0d3ea0f]1xBet промокод – получите до 100% бонуса[/url]
Кроме того, всегда стоит следить за новостями на 1xBet, где регулярно обновляются промокоды. Информация о спортивных турнирах может быть полезна для ставок, и свежие новости помогают выбрать лучшие моменты для участия.
Как использовать промокод 1xBet для получения бонуса? Ответ прост: зарегистрируйтесь на сайте, введите промокод и получите бонус за регистрацию. Все эти шансы открывают большие перспективы для игроков. Не упустите возможность увеличить свой депозит и воспользуйтесь эксклюзивными промокодами уже сейчас.
Таким образом, 1xBet бонусный код – это уникальная возможность для новых игроков, а легкость активации делает его выгодным выбором для тех, кто хочет начать с бонусом. Используйте код и увеличьте депозит прямо сейчас!
промокод на продамус [url=https://prodamus-promokod1.ru]промокод на продамус[/url] .
промокод на подключение продамуса [url=https://vc.ru/services/1527889-prodamus-promokod-vcru-skidka-dlya-podklyucheniya-2000-v-2024]промокод на подключение продамуса[/url] .
промокод Getcourse Pay [url=https://platezhnyj-modul-getkurs-promokod.ru]промокод Getcourse Pay[/url] .